SHLL 2023 Softball All Star Teams
| Juniors All Stars | Majors All Stars | 9-10-11 All Stars | 8-9-10 All Stars |
| Coach Stephanie Gilligan | Coach Chad Simon | Coach Josh Maiuri | Coach Justin Estell |
| |
| | |
| Victoria Bell | Paityn Calapp | Lilith Beach | Alexis Craig |
| Leah Brown | Cassidy Garrity | Lillyann Bellantonio | Karly Davis |
| Symantha Buras | Aubrey Gidley | Reagen Edlund | Scarlett Doran |
| Hadley Chamberlain | Bellamarie Hoover | Jesslyn Godsey | Brooklyn Estell |
| Natalie Chappell | Riley Humphrey | Addison Hansen | Kyla Gilderhus |
| Jade Gilligan | Jaycee Kemp | Jordyn Jenkins | Kylie Howard |
| Jayden Kraft | Addison Maples | Bryce Maiuri | Raegan Humphrey |
| Claire Mauch | Michie Ngotel | Natalie Marshall | Avery Kraft |
| Addilynn Morey | Kendall Rein | Kaianne Nieblas | Bryn Lambert |
| Ellie Pruitt | Hazel Rondeau | Ava Petorak | Brynn Landry |
| Kallie-ann Sullivan | Riley Rooney | Cassidy Porter | Maddie Mosesso |
| Kennedy Thompson | Nalani San Nicolas | Laurel Rosseels | Nora Pruitt |
| Madison Watson | Finley Simon | | Emmalin Vasquez |